Kekuatan Mengikat Order Mahkamah Internasional pada Kasus Karl LaGrand

  • Liviani Kristanti Fakultas Hukum Universitas Surabaya, Raya Kalirungkut, Surabaya 60293-Indonesia
  • Wisnu Aryo Dewanto Fakultas Hukum Universitas Surabaya, Raya Kalirungkut, Surabaya 60293-Indonesia
  • Suhariwanto Suhariwanto Fakultas Hukum Universitas Surabaya, Raya Kalirungkut, Surabaya 60293-Indonesia
Abstract Views: 149 PDF Downloads: 75
Keywords: order, bindingforce, internationalcourt of justice

Abstract

AbstractThis study discusses the strength of binding orders from the International Court of Justice for countries in dispute. Orders from the International Court of Justice are often violated, because they are considered to have no binding power and no harsh sanctions. The international court has issued an order to stop the execution of the death penalty for Karl LaGrand, a German citizen living in the United States. However, the United States still carried out the execution to Karl LaGrand. This study uses a juridical-normative method which is studied through a statute approach and a conceptual approach to achieve results. The results of the study show that orders from the International Court of Justice have binding power because the order is a decision of the International Court of Justice that must be implemented and obeyed by the disputing country.
Keywords: order, bindingforce, internationalcourt of justice 

Abstrak—Penelitian ini membahas tentang kekuatan mengikat order dari Mahkamah Internasional bagi negara yang bersengketa. Order dari Mahkamah Internasional sering kali di langgar,  karena dianggap tidak memiliki kekuatan mengikat dan tidak ada sanksi yang keras. Mahkamah internasioal telah mengeluarkan order untuk menghentikan eksekusi pidana mati bagi Karl LaGrand yang merupakan seorang warga negara Jerman yang tinggal di Amerika Serikat. Namun eksekusi mati tetap dilaksanakan oleh Amerika Serikat kepada Karl LaGrand. Penelitian ini menggunakan metode yuridis-normatif yang dikaji melalui statute approach dan conceptual approach untuk mencapai hasil. Hasil kajian menunjukan bahwa order dari Mahkamah Internasional memiliki kekuatan mengikat karena order merupakan putusan Mahkamah Internasional yang harus dilaksanakan dan dipatuhi oleh negara yang bersengketa. 
Kata kunci: order, kekuatan mengikat, mahkamah internasional

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bigelow, M. (1880). History of Procedure in England.

Dewanto, W. A. (2005). MahkamahInternasional. Sidoarjo: Citramedia.

Frowein, J. A. (2002). Provisional Measures by the International Court of Justice. The LaGrand Case , 56.

Gross. (1976). The Future of International Court of Justice.

Hellbeck, E. (1985). Provisional Measure of The International Court of Justice: Are They Binding? Association of Student International Law Societies International Law Journal 9 , 169-187.

Holdsworth. (1916). The Relation of the Equity Administered by the Chancellor. New Haven: Yale L.J.

Hudson, M. O. (1920-1942, 1943). The Permanent Court of International Justice. 425.

Humbro, E. (1956). The Binding Character of the Provisional Measures of Protection Indicated by the International Court of Justice. Geburstag: Rechtsfagen der ZnternationalenOrganisation.

Kempen, B., & He, Zen. (2009). The Recent Development. The Practice of The International Court of Justice on Provisional Measures , 925.

Kerly, D. M. (1890). An Historical Sketch of The Equitable Jurisdiction of The Court of Chancery. Cambridge: University Press.

Oellers-Frahm, K. (2006). The Statute of The International Court of Justice : A Commentary. First Edition OUP , 962.

Rosenne, S. (1965). The Law and Practice of The International Court. Leiden. Rosenne, S. (2005). Provisional Measures in International Law. The International Court of Justice and The International Tribunal for The Law of Sea , 33.

Sloane, R. D. (2007). Measures Necessary to Ensure: The ICJ's Provisional Measures Order in Avena and Other Mexican Nationals. Boston: Boston University ofLaw.
Published
2020-10-28
How to Cite
Kristanti, L., Dewanto, W. A., & Suhariwanto, S. (2020). Kekuatan Mengikat Order Mahkamah Internasional pada Kasus Karl LaGrand. KELUWIH: Jurnal Sosial Dan Humaniora, 1(2), 60-67. https://doi.org/10.24123/soshum.v1i2.3134
Share |

Most read articles by the same author(s)